uncover the facts
Pumpkin vs. Fetch Pet Insurance
See how Fetch’s coverage is more pumped-up than Pumpkin.
Enroll today



UNMATCHED COVERAGE
Fetch covers what Pumpkin pet insurance doesn’t, including:
Full-mouth dental coverage, including periodontal disease, oral trauma and more.
Pumpkin doesn’t cover every tooth.
Up to 100% reimbursement on pet medications when you order from Fetch Pet Rx.†
Pumpkin doesn’t do that.
24/7 telehealth treatment.
Pumpkin doesn’t cover online vet visits.
fetch value
Compare Fetch to Pumpkin
Coverage | ||
|---|---|---|
$1,000/yr. in online vet visits $0 copay! $0 deductible! | ||
$1,000/yr. in behavioral therapy $0 copay! $0 deductible! | ||
Online pharmacy 100% reimbursement† | ||
Every tooth, plus gums up to your max limit | Less coverage than Fetch | |
Sick-visit exam fees | ||
Covers pets of every age 6 weeks+ | ||
Alternative & holistic care | ||
Use any vet in the U.S. & Canada | ||
Vitamins & supplements | ||
Discounts on pet products & services included in your policy benefits* | Costs extra |
†Subject to deductible and policy limit; applies to qualifying medications purchased from Fetch Pet Rx. *Discounts on pet products & services are not insurance and are not provided by AXIS Insurance Company. All coverage is subject to policy limit. This comparison is based on core policy coverage and the information is accurate as of January 2025. Comparison of online pharmacy and discounts on pet products & services based on each provider's website as of April 2025.
Pumpkin’s limitations on dental coverage could cost you thousands
Fetch Pet Insurance covers injury and disease in every adult tooth, not just the canines. Plus, you get full coverage for periodontal disease (the most common disease in dogs and cats), oral tumors, trauma and more.
Pumpkin’s dental coverage doesn’t include endodontic or orthodontic dental services like caps, crowns, crown amputations, fillings, implants or root canals. Dental coverage is not an area you want to skimp on — especially since treatment like root canals can cost thousands of dollars.


With Fetch, you’ll get up to 100% reimbursement on pet meds†
Fetch reimburses up to 100% of your out-of-pocket expenses on medications when you order from online pharmacy Fetch Pet Rx.
Pumpkin doesn’t offer this. Fetch is the only pet insurance provider that pays you back up to 100% of the cost of your pet’s meds — with $0 copay — when you use Fetch Pet Rx.
Pumpkin doesn’t cover online vet visits, but Fetch does
Fetch includes 24/7 telehealth treatment, so you can call, text, email or video chat with a licensed vet to get support. Online vet visits are covered up to $1,000 a year — no copay, no deductible, no additional costs.
Pumpkin does not cover virtual vet visits. Their telehealth coverage (which costs extra) is limited to a 24/7 helpline where you can get guidance about your pet’s health and behavior, but they can’t diagnose your pet or provide a treatment plan.


With Fetch, you’ll get $1,500+ in instant savings on top pet brands
Shop food, treats, training and more with Fetch Health Perks. Your exclusive savings start the day you enroll — no waiting.
Pumpkin charges extra to join their perks program.
Fetch’s app makes it easy to submit claims and get paid fast — Pumpkin doesn’t have an app
Snap photos of your documents, send them to us and we’ll do the rest.
Pumpkin does not have a dedicated app. You need to submit claims via their online member center.


Fetch covers more than just vet bills
If your pet goes missing, we want to help. Fetch covers the cost of advertising that your pet is lost and paying a reasonable reward for finding them. Your plan includes coverage up to $1,000 per year.
Pumpkin doesn’t offer this.
Fetch offers coverage for boarding fees. Pumpkin doesn’t.
We’ll cover up to $1,000 of your pet’s boarding fees because we’re not just here for your pet. Should you require hospitalization for 4 days or more, we’ve got you covered.
Pumpkin doesn’t cover boarding fees, so if you’re ever hospitalized, you’ll likely need to pay someone else to take care of your pet.

FETCH PET INSURANCE REVIEWS
Read our 5-star reviews on Trustpilot
Fetch comparison FAQS
What should you consider when comparing pet insurance providers?
When should I sign up?
What does the coverage include?
How much can you customize the price?
What matters the most to you?
At Fetch, we understand how special your pet is to you (and vice-versa). That’s why we built a plan that covers more of the care your pet needs. Having more coverage means you’ll never have to choose between a vet bill and your pet’s health — so they can have a longer, happier life, and you can both have more good days together.

